• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Lenny’s Pizzeria

At Lenny's Pizzeria, pizza is more than just food; it's a vibrant tradition echoed through generations. Nestled in Farmingdale, NY, this beloved establishment has earned a reputation for its exceptional pizza, including gluten-free options, and a menu that celebrates Italian cuisine. With commitment to quality, Lenny's uses fresh ingredients to craft delicious dishes that keep patrons returning. The warm, welcoming atmosphere enhances the dining experience, making it perfect for families and groups. As Lenny's transitions to new ownership, the essence of its dedication to exceptional food and service remains unwavering. Here, every slice is a masterpiece, inviting you to savor the comfort of home.

LOCATIONS

Welcome to Lenny's Pizzeria, a vibrant culinary gem located at 199 Merritts Rd, Farmingdale, NY. Here, you can indulge in a delightful fusion of Italian cuisine featuring a wide variety of pizzas, hearty salads, and more. Lenny’s stands out not just for its appetizing menu but for its welcoming atmosphere that caters to all!

  • Delivery & Takeout: Perfect for those cozy nights in or busy afternoons when you need a tasty meal on-the-go.
  • Reservations: Planning a gathering? Lenny’s ensures that you can secure a table for groups, making it a fantastic spot for gatherings of all sizes.
  • Accessibility: The restaurant is wheelchair accessible, guaranteeing that everyone can enjoy a slice of heaven.
  • Family-Friendly: With offerings that cater to kids and a casual dress code, Lenny’s is a welcomed destination for family outings.
  • Gluten-Free Options: Noted for its exceptional gluten-free pizza that has garnered praise from loyal patrons!
  • Outdoor Seating: Enjoy your meal al fresco with both heated and covered outdoor seating options available.
  • Community Spirit: The warm and friendly service is a constant, with staff ensuring you feel right at home.

Lenny's Pizzeria has garnered glowing reviews from customers. Paula A. highlights it as her top choice for both pizza and dinner dishes, consistently delivering satisfaction. Vida S. raves about their gluten-free pizza, praising the responsive service which adds a personal touch. David E. expresses his love for the ingredients’ quality, voicing that every bite speaks volumes about the care and attention striking through the dishes.

Your mouth will water at the mention of specialty slices like the vodka slice, or the classic white pizza, both of which have garnered acclaim. Add to that a serving of garlic knots, and you are set for an unforgettable meal.

Though the pizzeria transitioned to new ownership and was rebranded as Popa’s, the heart and soul of the original Lenny’s still resonate throughout. The remodeled ambiance remains familiar yet refreshed, embodying a spirit ready for revitalization and community connection.

If you're searching for a spot that combines delicious food, a family-friendly atmosphere, and a welcoming community vibe, visit Lenny's Pizzeria or the newly minted Popa’s. Your taste buds will thank you!

For more information, contact them at (516) 586-5600 and get ready to savor exquisite flavors at this beloved local establishment.

START YOUR REVIEW OF Lenny’s Pizzeria
Paula A.
Paula A.

Lenny's is my pizza place of choice for pizza and their dinner dishes. I only order in and I am never disappointed. I recommend this restaurant.

Vida S.
Vida S.

My favorite gluten free pizza! And they have great service. They will call me if there is an issue or question.

David E.
David E.

So friendly, so delicious. Quick delivery reasonably priced. They do not skimp on anything. You can taste the quality. Do not change a thing you are my go to place.

Genna A.
Genna A.

Now called Popa's Delicious Pizza! Love the slice Love the square Love the white pizza Love the vodka slice

Nancy R.
Nancy R.

Orlando now owns what was once Lenny's. It's now called Papas due to the negativity the neighborhood felt from the previous owner who took over after Lenny's family sold the pizzeria. The interior is the same, no side display case anymore. They don't make the little pizza and broccoli rabe bites, but the pizza makes up for that. I had a white slice. The kids had spinach roll and regular slices and they said it was really good. They also loved the garlic knots. Orlando was very welcoming and we wish him lots of success with his revamping a beloved pizzeria and making it his own!

Barbara C.
Barbara C.

Now changed to poppas pizza Great Lots of selections Great service Remodeled store Clean

Elizabeth B.
Elizabeth B.

I died and went to heaven while eating this. There's your average "put cheese and fat on everything and it'll taste good", and then there are masterpieces like this that take comfort food to the next level